Indigenous land rights: is modernization the answer?

An indigenous woman in Arimae mixes jagua inkAn indigenous woman in Arimae mixes jagua inkIn an article entitled “Can Free Market Economics Boost Amazonian Land Rights?” Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto proposes that modern property rights are the key to propelling indigenous communities with communal land out of poverty. He believes that breaking up collective lands and establishing individual titles will enable community members to gain access to capital and credit, allowing them to become part of the global economy.

Indigenous communities like our partner Arimae utilize collective land ownership to ensure the economic, social, and cultural way of life for all members of the community. Even with established titles from their national governments, Indigenous groups worldwide are at risk from outsiders appropriating their natural resources for their own gain.

The problem is not the absence of land titles, but the deficiency of the State in enforcing collective ownership as equal to that of private ownership.

Land titles are important because they eliminate issues of ownership and create an indisputable definition of property rights. As a fundamental piece of the Equitable Forestry model, our partners provide proof of land ownership before any contracts are signed or planting takes place.

We strive to work with individuals who have a long term vision of cultivating their land in a sustainable manor while maintaining the area’s rich biodiversity. These tenets are inherent in indigenous cultures with communal lands which is why we support their struggle to obtain equal property rights and maintain control of their land.

FSC certification and pricing update

a cocobolo tree in the Friends and Family plantation showing strong growthA cocobolo tree in our Friends and Family plantation demonstrating strong growthThe ITTO's most recent timber report included an anecdote about a Peruvian logging concessionaire receiving FSC certification for its operations in Madre de Dios. They noted the large enterprise could barely afford the certification and annual verification process, and is seeing no prospect of better pricing because of the FSC certification. This makes sense considering that India and China are major purchasers and are not as demanding regarding timber certifications. It appears that producers with more direct sales channels into the US and/or Europe are in a better position to capture the higher pricing that FSC certification provides.

While we manage our investor-owned plantations to exceed FSC certification standards we have yet to actually certify those plantations due to the high cost and the current small scale of our operations. Once timber production from our plantations begins, we will analyze the market conditions when production comes on line to see whether the price premium validates the cost of certification. 

The ITTO also reports that timber demand and prices are holding steady across the globe. Pricing for plantation teak (Panamanian included) arriving into the Indian market held steady after a recent bump. Flooring originating from China is now being hit by anti-dumping levies by the US, so that will potentially depress demand slightly. However, a long term study of timber needs in Australia was pointing to the lack of local supply and the need to increase imports in the future.

Have your [cacao] and eat it, too

Planting Empowerment employee Liriano tends to a cacao sapling planted for the UNDP projectConventional thinking by most agronomists holds that creating a more biodiverse field or planting area ultimately reduces yields. However, a recent study entitled "Combining High Biodiversity With High Yields in Tropical Agroforests" suggests just the opposite: that increased yields and biodiversity can go hand-in-hand. The article, authored by Clough et al., examined biodiverse cacao (cocoa) plantations in Indonesia. 

Last year through the UNDP's Small Grants Program we worked with Arimae to plant cacao in some of their older tree plantations. Arimae planted some of the cacao beneath the canopy of a 10-year old mahogany stand, and the rest in a new parcel of rosewood with more sun exposure. We will be closely monitoring the differences in growth and yield between the two parcels as they mature and begin to produce.

Read More

Bolivian big leaf mahogany (swietenia macrophylla) threatened

The International Tropical Timber Association (ITTO) recently released its bi-weekly report on global timber prices.

One of the highlights of the report was a classification by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) of Bolivia's big leaf mahogany (swietenia macrophylla) as a "species of urgent concern". CITES recommended that Bolivia place a moratorium on its export.

Read More

Website Redesign

As our business grows, our website is also growing to capture and convey this evolution. So, PlantingEmpowerment.com is getting a makeover.  

To ensure that you have a great experience on our new website, we want to get your feedback on our current website.

Can you take 3 minutes to share your thoughts using a short survey? We'd really appreciate it!

Go to the Survey >